Category Archives: Education

Natural and Artificial Persons

So I did a deranged thing earlier this month, and wrote an alphabet verse about the Theology of Personhood and AI.  Some of you will love it and some of you will hate it, and some of you will just think it is too long!  But from a purely literary point of view, I’m pretty sure this is the best thing I’ve ever written (and probably the best thing I ever will write).  So I hope this gets shared widely enough that it finds its own audience:

Natural and Artificial Persons

I posted it earlier this month on Substack.  But this isn’t an announcement that I’m moving to Substack.  I don’t even know yet if there is going to be a second Substack post!  I know that serious thinkers, who want people to respect their AI takes, are expected to build their audience by writing 15 posts a week, and maybe also found a self-help movement or two to drive additional viral community engagment, but I don’t really have it in me to do that.  How about if you guys just do that stuff without me, and pretend I was involved?

At minimum, the posts more appropriate to my original set of topics will stay here at Undivided Looking.

The reason that I selected the name Undivided Looking (besides it being a rare enough word-pair to not match anything else on google search at the time), is because I believe that it is important to think about life from a unified perspective—notably including both scientific and religious topics—without compartmentalizing (at least not all the time).  But I’m not sure I’ve done a very good job with that.  Perhaps because I have a very high threshold for what topics make me motivated enough to actually sit down and type: in practice this blog has only captured only a very small fraction of the things I actually care about.  I tried to write about the most important things and I discovered that this was too narrow and constrained.  But it turns out I’m not manic enough to give you my perspective on the whole world, the way that perhaps I should have been doing all along.

When people talk about trying to reconstruct writers’ personalities using AI, that’s just total ridiculous nonsense.  There are several of my hobbies and interests, and lots of obvious facts that my family and friends know about me, that have never graced these pages.  That may be in part just my own limitations as a writer.  All I can say is that the verse I linked to above comes from my soul and not just my mind.  It feels like it took me 42 years to write it (that’s how old I am)—even though I finished editing it a fortnight after I wrote the first word.  I prepped 13 pages of handwritten notes to write a series of a dozen-or-so blog posts, and then I never looked at any of them and I never wrote any of the posts.  So don’t expect another piece like this one until I’m 84, I think that’s what I’m getting at here.  I’m certainly not making any claims about the quality of this post, this one is just because I had to write something and not just plop down a link without any explanation.

Also, happy All Saints Day, when we commemorate all the holy persons who have lived throughout history, including those known only to God.  Can a robot be holy?  I’m not going to answer that question here.  I’ll just say this: if they can’t tell that I’m speaking to them, then I’m not.

A Path to Practical Wisdom

Here is one way to become wise:

1. Start by getting really good at one or more skills.  It isn’t important how useful the skill is for “real life”; it only requires that it be something difficult which requires you to improve.  It could be gardening, video games, cooking, sports, or whatever.  This requires:

a. large amounts of practice
b. feedback from reality — notice what works and what doesn’t.
c. take the feedback into account and change what you do so that it works better
d. but it is okay to deliberately experiment with making “mistakes” as long as they contribute to learning.

2. Now formulate the lessons you learned from #1 as maxims:

a. try to put it into words (though some people do it more intuitively).  Keep it simple enough to remember, and abstract enough that it has a chance of applying to OTHER situations as well.
b. notice when it actually does so
c. take this wisdom into account when dealing with the other subject matter.
d. but every rule has exceptions!  You can’t list all the exceptions, so only obey the maxim when it actually makes sense to do so, or when you are deliberately trying it out as an experiment to see what happens.

3. Other people are probably better than you at discovering maxims:

a. learn from people who are doing this
b. but recognize that the maxims (2) are based on an invisible pyramid of observations (1) and can’t be appreciated without you doing some amount of 1 and 2 yourself
c. so you still have to check what actually makes sense and works!  Just because it sounds good doesn’t mean it is useful to YOU (or anyone).
d. even wise people can still be idiots, especially when they trust too much in their own wisdom.  (But sometimes it is good to experiment with trusting too much to see what happens as a result, etc.)

In all of the above, there are two completely different kinds of risk, one good and one bad:

DANGEROUS RISK that will possibly seriously hurt you, or things/people you care about.  The wise person almost always steers widely clear of this.  The only exception is a risk for great gain, and even then it is usually better to formulate an alternative safer plan.  (But if your heart tells you to put yourself in danger, sometimes you need to put yourself in danger.)

SAFE RISK where failure is primarily a learning experience with no permanent harm.  The wise person seeks out this kind of risk on a regular basis, because learning is extremely important, especially if you want to avoid dangerous risks!

Some amount of moderation is needed to ensure you can emotionally recover.  If failure hurts enough to make you reject future learning, then that was actually a dangerous risk!  But usually the difference between these kinds of risk is assessed objectively, not based on your feelings.

All of this is more oriented around how to excel at whatever you put your mind to, rather than what your goals should be in the first place.  There is also a spiritual wisdom that enables us to have the correct goals (hint: worship God and serve him alone) but this post isn’t really about that more important subject.  It’s more about how to get better at practical applications of life skills.

Perhaps there is some even higher perspective from which practical wisdom and spiritual wisdom eventually converge and become the same thing.  This blog post isn’t exactly about that either.  That is, I won’t tell you how the convergence happens, but it is possible that if you pursue wisdom heartily enough, you will find this out on your own (possibly by straying from the techniques mentioned above, if you learn that something else works better).

Need Help with Writing?

My wife has spent nearly a decade teaching people how to become better at writing.

If you are 16 years or older, and you need help learning how to write a good academic essay — no, she won’t write it for you, that’s plagiarism! — then please check out St. Nicole’s online tutoring service.

She has a lot of experience with ESL students.  She also offers copyediting, if that’s what you need.

She’s got two masters degrees, and lots of teaching experience.

What is the connection between this and my usual science and religion fare?  Well that’s simple.  THIS content (on my blog, anyway) is always going to be free.  But if you’d like to support us, you can always go over there and pay for THAT content.

Prizes

I’ve recently won a pretty big prize in theoretical physics, called the New Horizons Prize.  This is a smaller version of the Breakthrough Prize which is awarded to more junior researchers.

My prize is shared with MIT’s Daniel Harlow and Harvard’s Daniel Jafferis, both of them excellent physicists.   Amusingly, each pair of us have written exactly 1 article together (but we have never collaborated as a trio).

I hope it is not too vain to share some news articles about the prize, in case people want to know more:

There is also going to be a prize ceremony today [i.e. the day I am writing this post], Sunday Nov 4th, in Mountain View.  You can find more information about the broadcasting of the event, and the other prize winners, here.  There will also be an all-day symposium at UC Berkeley this Monday, at which I will be getting the actual trophy and also we will be speaking at a panel on whether time travel is possible.  You can watch it live streamed here.

I’ve also recently received the 2018 Philippe Meyer Prize and the IUPAP Young Scientist Prize [alt link], both of whose award ceremonies will be in the future.

After all this shameless self-promotion, I have some even better news that makes me even prouder: in January Nicole and I are expecting our first child, a son!  We are so pleased by this, and hope that he will find this world hospitable as God’s will is accomplished in his life.  I don’t feel prepared yet to be a father, but then again no one ever is.  I understand that children are very good at training up their parents, so hopefully it will turn out all right!

Crossing the Ocean

For the last several months I’ve been very busy with job interviews and I haven’t had much time to actually think about Physics, let alone blog about it.  Sorry to everyone whose comments I’ve neglected in the meantime, but I hope you were having fun discussing among yourselves…

That brings us to a major life announcement.  Last week I’ve accepted a Lectureship at the University of Cambridge!  (Yes, the one in England.)  Needless to say, I was shocked, humbled, and flattered (all at once) when I heard I would be getting an offer a few weeks ago.  So starting Jan 1st, 2019 (Lord willing and the visa come) I’ll be a faculty member at the 4th oldest University in the world (after Bologna, Paris, and Oxford)*.  Nicole and I are very excited!  Until this new job begins, I remain at Stanford.

The faculty job ranks in the UK go like this: Lecturer → Reader → Professor.  This is roughly equivalent to Assistant Professor → Associate Professor → Full Professor in the USA, but unfortunately it means you can’t call me “professor” yet while anyone from the UK is listening.  That includes here on the internet, sorry.

In another shocking twist of convention (and I’m sure it won’t be the last) Theoretical Physics is considered a subcategory of Maths in the UK (note the Britishised spelling, which gives the term its own local colour).  Specifically I’ll be at DAMTP.  Apparently the Physics Department does something else, I guess they’re the folks who interact with the actual physical world?

The good news is, it seems I don’t have to worry about getting tenure.  Technically there’s a 5 year probationary period before I’d get appointed to retirement age, but apparently no one in Maths has ever been denied in living memory.  (Although you never know, I could always be the first—everyone’s always said I’m exceptional.)  Except for a few big names, the universities in the US like to reassure their junior hires that their tenure rates are in the high nineties.  But there’s a big difference between marrying a spouse who’s 95% likely to be faithful, and one who is virtually certain to be—it’s nice not to have to worry about it!

Cambridge has 31 affiliated colleges (like Baskin-Robbins and flavours), each with their own heraldic scarf colors.  The Lectures and Exams are set by the University Teaching Officers, while the College Fellows tutor the students in the material in groups of 1-3 students.  Unlike Oxford, membership in a college is optional for University faculty, and many people in math and science don’t.  But I think it would be cool (I mean, brilliant!) to dine with people working in completely different fields.  And while I’d like to believe I’ll do a good job lecturing, my talents shine best in a one-on-one setting, where I can adapt my approach to each student.  So I’ll definitely apply to join a college, but I don’t know which one yet.  We’ll just have to see what their Sorting Hat has to say about it.

Obviously, I’m sad not to be able to see Stephen Hawking after I arrive.  I was introduced to him a few years ago at a conference lunch in Brussels, but he was completely non-responsive at the time (he was eating).  But he did come to my talk the next day.  Now he has departed on a far more significant journey than my crossing to England will be…  I hope he is now at peace, and pray that he will find mercy and full healing when the Lord returns.  (Same goes for Joe Polchinski, a colleague from Santa Barbara who died a couple months ago of brain cancer.)  There are, however, lots of other superb gravitational theorists at Cambridge who are still among the earthly living, and I look forward to working with them.

* Disclaimer: History is always more fractaline than the simple narratives whenever you look at it closely, and this claim is no exception.  I went to Wikipedia to check it, and of course there are disputes about what counts as a University and what counts as its founding date.  It’s really old, let’s leave it at that.  (Needless to say, the views in this post are my own and do not necessarily reflect the views of Cambridge University.)